Bamboo is basically magic. The world’s fastest growing plant, bamboo can grow up to a metre in a single day, making it a more sustainable source for paper than trees. It’s no surprise that bamboo toilet paper has helped reshape bathroom habits for eco-conscious consumers, and bamboo toilet paper brands like Who Gives A Crap and PlantPaper have been leading the charge.

Curious how PlantPaper matches up with the toilet paper from Who Gives A Crap? From sustainability ratings to subscription perks, we’re pitting Who Gives A Crap against PlantPaper to help you pick your perfect match. Let’s dive in.

What do we need to know about PlantPaper?

Since 2016, PlantPaper has been carving out its niche in the eco-friendly toilet paper market with its bamboo based products. Their 3 ply, FSC certified bamboo toilet paper rolls boast 200 sheets of bleach-free, toxin-free paper designed with sustainability in mind.

PlantPaper’s package options range from 16 to 96 rolls, with subscription plans delivering every six to 24 weeks. You can also make a one time purchase, but be prepared for some sticker shock: $42 for 16 rolls or $165 for 96. Couple that with consumer complaints about the rolls’ rough texture, and PlantPaper’s premium price might not deliver the premium comfort you’d expect.

What’s the scoop with Who Gives A Crap?

At Who Gives A Crap, we’re rolling out toilet paper that makes a difference — for you and the planet. By donating 50% of our profits, we’re helping bring clean water and sanitation to those who need it most, with a goal of delivering a toilet to everyone in the world within our lifetime.

Following an infamously cheeky crowdfunding campaign, our founders delivered their first product in 2013 — we’ve been on a roll ever since. Today, we offer two eco-friendly TP options: premium 3 ply bamboo and soft, strong 100% recycled paper, with boxes available in 12, 24 or 48 rolls. (Not to mention a growing lineup of other household essentials).

With thousands of 5-star reviews, our customers clearly approve. While some think the texture takes some adjusting, they’re quick to make statements about the toilet paper’s strength and durability.

What’s the price per roll of PlantPaper vs Who Gives A Crap?

Looking at the biggest packages each brand offers — 96 rolls for PlantPaper and 48 rolls for Who Gives A Crap — the numbers don’t lie. PlantPaper’s pack costs $165*, putting the price at $1.72 per roll. Who Gives A Crap’s 48 roll package? Just $68, or $1.42 per roll.

But wait, there’s more! On a per sheet basis, Who Gives A Crap still holds the edge at $0.38 compared to PlantPaper’s $0.86. PlantPaper’s sheets may be ever so slightly larger (4x4 inches compared to Who Gives A Crap’s 3.94x3.94 inches), but the added size doesn’t make up for the price gap. (We promise your bum won’t notice).

*Note: The pricing comparisons from this section are accurate at the time of writing in August 2024. 

The verdict: PlantPaper vs Who Gives A Crap

It’s a photo finish! Both brands offer standout 3 ply bamboo toilet paper and are FSC certification helping reduce deforestation. But with flexible subscriptions, Who Gives A Crap takes the lead in roll size — 370 sheets compared to PlantPaper’s 200 — nearly double the length.

The tie breaker? Who Gives A Crap’s unbeatable value, the added option of 100% recycled paper, and a commitment to donate 50% of profits.

Conclusion: Who Gives A Crap toilet paper for the win

The scorecard was close, but it’s Who Gives A Crap toilet paper taking the victory lap.

PlantPaper’s products weigh heavily on the wallet, while Who Gives A Crap has the cost saving benefit of subscription prices. Providing bamboo and 100% recycled toilet paper is another big win for consumers who want variety and budget friendly options. When you scrunch the numbers, we beat out PlantPaper by $.50 a roll — even more when comparing price per sheet.

High marks are given to both PlantPaper and Who Gives A Crap for their sustainability ratings. All competition aside, we respect PlantPaper’s commitment to sustainability and are glad to see more brands stepping up.

Ready to call it? Try our bamboo toilet paper and see for yourself why it’s worth the switch.