As a gift for you entering our neck of the woods (the much more dense side), we will make the decision as easy as it can be. Starting with comparing two of the top environmentally friendly options: Plant Paper versus Hello Tushy.
Get ready to explore these brands' softness, durability, sustainability, and more to find the perfect pick for your eco-friendly bathroom routine. It's time to make your bathroom a little greener (in a good way).
What is Plant Paper?
Plant Paper, founded in 2016, stands out with its commitment to sustainability and quality. Their mission is dedicated to fostering a healthier planet through eco-friendly alternatives that prioritize ecological integrity and consumer well-being.
It specializes in eco-friendly toilet paper and facial tissues crafted entirely from 100% FSC-certified bamboo. This choice ensures that every product is bleach-free, formaldehyde-free, and PFAS-free, promoting a healthier environment for production and use.
Their packaging features a minimalist style, sleek cardboard exterior, and convenient handle. Imagine a swankier build-a-bear box and you've got the idea.
What are the benefits of Plant Paper?
Plant Paper stands out by producing eco-friendly toilet paper and facial tissues that feel just like traditional options but with the added benefit of reducing environmental impact.
They claim to have set a new industry benchmark for softness with their thicker, more absorbent three-ply design and unique double-sided embossing pattern.
With a larger sheet size and 100% plastic-free packaging, Plant Paper emphasizes that it is a trade-up, not a trade-off.
Their efforts have granted them a B+ from the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), an international environmental advocacy group that rates companies' sustainable efforts.
What are the downsides of Plant Paper?
Plant Paper, renowned for its commitment to sustainability, chooses not to individually wrap its products. This choice might affect how it's perceived on the shelf and for personal use.
It's a small detail but one worth considering for those who prioritize cleanliness and presentation in their bathroom essentials.
Adding to the decision-making mix, Plant Paper comes at a price—a big one. It sits nearly 20 cents higher per sheet than other sustainable brands.
There's also no free shipping on single purchases, so if you want to try it, be cautious that it will be an investment.
What is Hello Tushy?
Chances are, if you've heard about Hello Tushy, it has something to do with their bidets. But since then, they've entered the eco-friendly bathroom market, offering scents, cleaners, and bamboo toilet paper.
Hello Tushy, also known as Tushy, was founded in 2015. It has partnered with Samagra, a nonprofit dedicated to building community toilets in India. Its mission is to improve health and dignity for disadvantaged communities.
What are the benefits of Hello Tushy?
Hello Tushy is proud to offer 3-ply toilet paper rolls. Their commitment to eco-friendliness extends further with bamboo toilet paper that is unbleached, BPA-free, and ECF-free, ensuring a clean and healthy choice for your personal care routine.
Specifically designed to complement Tushy bidets, this toilet paper is prepared to absorb water without compromising strength or comfort. They are so confident in their design that they claim that all you need is just two squares, and you're good to go, literally.
A unique selling point they offer is a no-roll option. Instead of wrapped in a traditional cardboard roll, they provide individual wipes, eliminating waste.
What are the downsides of Hello Tushy?
Limited to just two pack sizes, Hello Tushy is a one-size-fits-some deal that might leave you wanting more—or less, depending on your needs. It comes in packs of 8 or 36 only.
Despite its claims, some users find it not absorbent at all. As one disgruntled customer says, "The minute it gets wet, your hands get wet too—even if you double up."
Hello Tushy has 21 complaints on the Better Business Bureau (BBB), most relating to its customer service. That's not exactly the kind of hello tushy you were hoping for.
Despite their no-roll option, the NRDC rated Hello Tushy's sustainable efforts as a C (300). They noted that Hello Tushy is not FSC-certified.
What’s the price per roll of Hello Tushy vs Reel Toilet paper?
When considering a one-time purchase, the price per roll for Plant Paper is $1.72, calculated from $165 for 96 rolls. For Hello Tushy, the price per roll is $1.92, based on $69 for 36 rolls.
Since Plant Paper has 200 sheets per roll and Hello Tushy has 300, let’s look at the cost per 100 sheets. Plant Paper offers a cost per 100 sheets of $0.86 for a one-time purchase, while Hello Tushy provides a more economical option at $0.64 for the same purchase type.
In terms of the percentage discount offered for subscribing, Plant Paper gives an approximate 9.1% discount, and Hello Tushy offers around an 11% discount.
Regarding sustainability, Plant Paper holds a higher NRDC sustainability rating with a B+ (500), compared to Hello Tushy's C (300). This indicates that Plant Paper is more environmentally friendly based on the NRDC criteria.
The verdict: Plant Paper vs Hello Tushy
So who wins this (eco)mpetition?
It's hard to deny the price difference. Hello Tushy gives you much more bang for your buck. However, as we see with the sustainability scores, that bang might be more geared towards the environment than you thought.
Plant Paper wins when it comes to softness and durability. But Hello Tushy has a much better shelf appeal and is more sanitary for storage.
So, how do you pick a winner? A lot of it is based on preference. Do you want something better for the planet but comes bare and leaves your wallet the same?
Or do you want something more appealing to the eye and more feasible but sacrifices slightly on quality?
Only you can decide what—and when—to doo.
What’s the best alternative to Plant Paper vs Hello Tushy?
Imagine having it all. Well, with one brand, you can!
Who Gives A Crap offers two fantastic options: recycled and bamboo toilet paper. We compete roll-to-roll with Plant Paper, offering a sustainable and luxuriously soft 3-ply bamboo style while boasting an impressive sustainability rating of A (551) for recycled toilet paper.
But our brand isn't just competing—it's dominating the field. Not only do we offer competitive prices, we also donate 50% of its profits to a great cause.
Who Gives A Crap boasts even more shelf appeal than the alternatives with fun, eye-catching designs that will leave people wondering where you snagged it (please tell them).
You get it all: shelf appeal, durability, softness, and top sustainability ratings, all individually wrapped in a plastic-free and cost-effective package.
Sounds like a clear winner to me!
Conclusion: Sustainable toilet paper for the win!
Plant Paper shines with its softness and durability, though it does come with a price tag that some might call astronomical. Plus, no free single shipping makes it a tough sell for budgeting buyers.
They go all-in on sustainability with 100% plastic-free packaging but skip individual wrapping, which can affect how it's perceived on the shelf.
Hello Tushy enters the loo with wallet-friendly prices and a fantastic shelf appeal. However, some users find it less absorbent than hoped. It also lags behind Plant Paper in sustainability ratings.
The choice boils down to your priorities: splurge on plush or save fashionably.
But there is another option.
Who Gives A Crap offers both bamboo and recycled toilet paper that's soft, durable, and socially conscious—they donate half their profits! Plus, they've nailed it with their packaging.
So, why not pick the toilet paper that cleans up nicely while cleaning up the planet? Make the switch to Who Gives A Crap and feel good about every roll.